The honest version โ including the failure rate nobody quotes you.
Fuel, payment, insurance, maintenance reserve, tyres, permits, and your own wage. Until that number is real, every rate looks acceptable โ and that is precisely how most new operators fail.
Brokers commonly pay on 30-plus day terms while fuel and payments are immediate. Many operators who were profitable on paper ran out of cash anyway.
Load boards are the spot market and are the most competitive rates available. Direct shipper relationships and dedicated lanes pay better and are far steadier.
A second truck means a driver, more insurance, and your time moving from driving to managing. Many operators earn less at two trucks than at one, and only find out afterwards.
| Revenue stream | Pays | Scales |
|---|---|---|
| Spot market (load boards)Always available, most competitive rates. A floor, not a strategy. | Volatile | Good |
| Dedicated lanesPredictable miles and planning. The backbone of a stable operation. | Steady, moderate | Good |
| Direct shipper contractsCuts out the broker margin. Slow to win and worth the effort. | Best | Relationship-limited |
| Specialised freightReefer, flatbed, hazmat, oversize โ fewer competitors, higher barrier. | Premium | Equipment-limited |
| Regional / short haulMore stops, more home time. Often better per hour than per mile suggests. | Lower per mile | Good |
| Leasing to a carrierLess admin and steadier volume, at the cost of independence and rate. | Lower, predictable | Limited |
This is a regulated industry with real compliance weight: operating authority, USDOT and MC numbers, BOC-3, UCR, IFTA, hours-of-service and ELD rules, drug and alcohol clearinghouse enrolment, and CSA scoring all apply from day one. Insurance is the largest fixed cost and getting it wrong is existential. The failure statistics above are not a scare tactic โ treat a 70โ80% two-year exit rate as the base rate you are trying to beat, and be honest with yourself about how.
Run this against real numbers โ The same handbook inside the tool, on a worked example you can swap for your own spreadsheet. Free, no account.Figures are sourced from published industry research (IBISWorld, trade associations and regulator data) and are stated with their year. They describe typical conditions, not your situation. This is general information for business owners, not financial, tax, or legal advice.